Journal club — a forum of discussion for scientific dialectics
نویسنده
چکیده
In the sometimes hectic routines of daily academic work, it can be difficult to find opportunities for naturally creative encounters with our colleagues, where we can jointly focus methodological issues in research. Where do we find the time and place for constructive discussions on published research? And how can we foster such meetings? As a senior lecturer and researcher, I have a strong interest in research seminars in the field of clinical activity, as well as long-standing experience of coordinating and leading such seminars. I also gained extensive knowledge of seminar dynamics from my doctoral studies at the University of Linkö ping. Over the years, I have developed a particular way of working with seminars, aiming to contribute to the establishment of interdisciplinary research groups at the School of Health and Social Science, at Halmstad University. One of my ideas was to take advantage of the privileged position of our university , and the fact that it hosts a scientific journal and its Editor-in-Chief, Professor Lillemor Hallberg. This is why I started the Journal Club in 2006* the same year that the International Journal of Qualitative Studies on Health and Well-being was launched. Initially, I simply sent an invitation to my fellow researchers at the School of Health and Social Science, explaining the purpose of the meetings. The idea was to use the Journal Club to discuss selected articles from the International Journal of Qualitative Studies on Health and Well-being, and critically examine them. It is essential that the articles are distributed to participants well in advance, and that participants have had time to read the contents, so they are prepared to critically examine the aims, methods and results of the discussed articles. My vision with the meetings at the Journal Club was to give added impetus to scientific dialectics at the School, to develop a critical approach and deepen methodological understanding. We need a continuous reflection concerning qualitative research approaches and various standpoints with respect to research ethics, in order to increase methodological awareness in our research. In this way, the monthly seminars contribute to developing our competencies as researchers, as well as keeping our knowledge up-to-date. Another aim of the Journal Club is to be a discussion forum for interdisciplinary research issues , relating to health, lifestyles , well-being and the quality of life. Uniting a critical mass at our school, and bringing about an engaging discussion, allows …
منابع مشابه
Implementing an Interactive Discussion Forum
An Interactive Discussion Forum (IDF) is a tool for supporting interactive discussions involving video and audio communication. A forum is a form of structured discussion, more purposeful than informal communications, such as chats or mailing list; moreover it has an important role in achieving a sense of community and participation in the audience. During a forum the participants debate a pre-...
متن کاملDevelopment of EFL Teachers’ Engagement and Professional Identity: The Effect of Discussing Teacher Competences via E- Collaborative Discussion Forum
This study is a mixed method research that investigated the effect of electronic collaborative discussion forum on Iranian EFL teachers' engagement and professional identity and their development in terms of teachers‘ competences as they were engaged in collaborative teacher inquiry. For this purpose, 5 EFL teachers participated in 11 online forum discussion sessions. Before participating in di...
متن کاملAn Analysis of Social Presence and Cognitive Presence in Discussion Forum
An increase of asynchronous online discussions in website provides much opportunity for L2 learners from different global communities to be exposed to the target language at their own pace and time. However, no research looking at the essentials of social presence and cognitive presence in creating a supportive learning environment in such a context has been done. This study investigated the pa...
متن کاملOnline talking shops
Biologists have been using the internet as a forum for informal discussion — in the form of newgroups — for more than a decade. If you’re looking for the answer to a specific question, or simply want to float an idea with a group of like-minded people, there’s bound to be somewhere on the web you can do it. The challenge is to find the useful discussions among the ‘spam’. Two elements that cont...
متن کاملAsynchronous Online Discussion Forum: A Key to Enhancing Students’ Writing Ability and Attitudes in Iran
This paper focuses on the impact of an asynchronous online discussion forum on the development of students’ ability in and attitudes toward writing in English. Two groups of third-year students (N = 60) majoring in English were assigned to two treatment and control groups, each receiving different types of feedback. Students in the treatment group were required to participate ...
متن کامل